New Sibling on the Way

Dear Mama,Dear Miss Faith, My daughter (age 3) is very close to me and I her. She really is a miracle because we tried for 10 years before she came. I am so blessed that she is here and I find myself a bit over protective of her and less authoritive because of this. However…we are soon to be expecting our second child (October) which was kind of a surprise since we were never successful before and are thrilled that our daughter will have a baby brother to love and play with. Right now, she really “wants” her mommy and I go to her when she needs me. However I am sensing that there is going to be a huge adjustment for her to see me with a new child. I am planning on having her involved in everything like being mommy’s helper with diapers, feeding etc., but I still see this as an adjustment for when I have bonding/loving time with the new baby. Do you have any suggestions on this? I am also planning on getting her a gift that when she comes to the hospital, it will be from the baby. Maybe a doll?

Dear Mama,

My first thought for preparing for the baby is for YOU to start playing with a dolly of hers that she already has, to practice what it will be like when the new baby comes. Start rocking the dolly, nursing the dolly, putting the dolly to bed when you put her to bed. At the beginning, always hand the dolly over to her whenever she wants it, but gradually start asking her to wait until you get to a ‘good stopping point’ (first just a few seconds, and gradually longer and longer). Give the dolly a name, and have it ‘cry,’ be ‘sleeping’ etc., throughout the day. This can give your daughter some practical practice as to what having a baby sibling will be like for her, and perhaps it won’t be such a shock to the system when the real one arrives. An added advantage to doing this is that it will make her dolly ‘come alive,’ so when the baby actually comes, she can have her own baby who already has a personality and needs that are similar to the baby’s. This can both give her something imitative to do when you’re busy with the baby, and she can use the dolly to act out her feelings towards her sibling, nurturing it sometimes, punishing it other times.

I think it’s a nice gesture to have a gift ‘from the baby’ for her when the baby’s born, but I’m not sure that another doll is the best idea, if you’re putting all this energy into having her current doll ‘come alive.’ Perhaps something FOR the doll, like a special blanket, or a doll bed, or sling, or something. Preferably something similar to something you’ll be using.

After the baby arrives, the important message will be to let her know (either through words or actions) that 1) it’s fine to feel whatever she’s feeling, and that 2) regardless of how she’s feeling, she must still act appropriately. But not to worry, you will help her figure out ways to act appropriately, and you love her so much. So, if you’re nursing and she wants you and she’s having trouble waiting, and starts to throw a little fit, give her the words, by saying exactly what you wish she would say: “You’re saying, ‘Mom, I want you SO MUCH! I’m having a hard time waiting!'” Give her a chance to repeat it, then answer her as if she had said it, whether she does or not: “Wow, I can SEE that you’re having a hard time! What will you do while you wait?” Pause a moment to see if she has any ideas for herself, then give a suggestion: “You could come here and sit right next to me, if you want. That way we can still feel close.” She may well come up with her own idea, at that point.

One thing I’d suggest avoiding is trying to hold/juggle both children at once. A few moms manage it gracefully, but with most moms I’ve seen, it turns into a tugging match where neither child feels like they’re getting enough of you, especially as the baby start to get older. I think it’s much better to help children learn to wait, then give them the whole of your attention (even if it’s only briefly).

For you moms out there with two kids, what have you done that worked well for you? What would steer clear of, if you could do it over again? What advice would you give to someone with a second on the way?


  1. I would also like to hear comments as I unexpectedly had two little girls very close together. They are 11 months apart. The youngest is now 9 months, and the older is 20 months. And I struggle with this on a daily basis – hitting and biting and crying for mom’s attention, not wanting to share laps or book reading time. Any advice would be so helpful! As for the prep, my 1st was very young and there wasn’t much that could be done to explain to her, in a way she could understand, the kind of change that was about to take place. We read books and talked about the baby living in the tummy. We birthed at home. So when my oldest awoke in the morning, there was her new baby sister. It was the best we could do to just be loving and patient and let her explore on her own terms. But, now that they are both toddling around, it’s like mass chaos!

  2. Lauren, I’ve seen this a lot, esp. with parents who have kids less than a year apart. It seems to be harder than twins somehow: they’re close enough that you want to do the same things for each, but not *quite* at the same stage, so it often doesn’t quite work.

    One thing that I’ve experienced is that sharing is much more difficult than taking turns, for little ones. This is true for toys (see my post on sharing vs. taking turns) but it seems to be true of mama, too. The moms who handle kids that close together gracefully seem to have taught their kids to wait with (relative) equanimity, knowing that they’ll get all of mom’s attention soon enough. Other moms: what has worked for you with two toddlers?

  3. Dhanya Smtih says

    Oh this is a great post! We just have a couple days or weeks until our new baby arrives, but I think I’ll start handling my son’s doll more consistently and in the way you’ve described. My son is 2.5 and has a baby doll, it’s been very helpful for all that baby gear that just CAN’T take a 35lb toddler in it but I always say something like, “You can put your baby in it, can you rock her back and forth, does she like that?” Another thing I’ve done is to get a bench glider instead of a traditional rocking chair, so there will be room for my 1st born to sit NEXT to me while I nurse, and read a book, play snuggle, whatever. I hope this works, because my lap is surely not big enough for 2 boys!

  4. My sister has 4 years old daughter and 1 years old son, at first I thought she will be tired taking care of 2 kids but what surprised me when dropping by her house, I saw the sister can help her mom by feeding her brother and singing to entertain. How 4 years old kid could do such a thing? What do you think, Miss Faith? thanks


  1. […] new achievement that baby makes as he grows. When your due date gets closer, read my post about New Sibling on the Way for ideas to help the transition, and other posts on Sibling Interactions as […]

Share Comments on this Post:


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Send Your Own Question to Miss Faith

Have a question about toddlers? Submit it to Miss Faith. She will respond to as many questions as she can, and may post it on the website! (Your name will not be used).


Get every new post on this blog delivered to your Inbox.

Join other followers: